Element 1 Question 1-19D5
C1D19: Antennas
What advantage does a vertical whip have over a long wire?
- It radiates more signal fore and aft.
- It radiates equally well in all directions. (correct answer)
- It radiates a strong signal vertically.
- None of the above.
Correct answer: B, It radiates equally well in all directions.
Explanation
A quarter-wave vertical whip is omnidirectional in the horizontal plane, so it sends and receives equally well toward every compass bearing. That suits a ship whose heading keeps changing relative to the stations it works. A long-wire antenna is directional, and its lobes depend on its length in wavelengths and how it is strung, so some bearings get a weaker signal.
Why the other answers are wrong
- A, It radiates more signal fore and aft.: Favoring fore and aft would be a directional pattern. The whip's advantage is that it favors no direction around the horizon.
- C, It radiates a strong signal vertically.: A vertical antenna has a null straight up along its own axis. Its energy goes out toward the horizon, not skyward.
- D, None of the above.: There is a real advantage: the whip's even coverage at all bearings, which a directional long wire lacks.