Element 3 Question 3-100Q5
C3Q100: Safety Steps
Do shorted-stub lightning protectors work at all frequencies?
- Yes.
- No, the short also kills the radio signals.
- No, the short enhances the radio signal at the tuned band.
- No, only at the tuned frequency band. (correct answer)
Correct answer: D, No, only at the tuned frequency band.
Explanation
A shorted quarter-wave stub across the feed line gives a direct DC path to ground for lightning's low-frequency energy. At its design frequency, the quarter-wave section transforms the short into a very high impedance, so the RF passes almost unaffected. Away from that band the stub no longer looks open, so it loads down or shorts the line. It works only on the band it is cut for.
Why the other answers are wrong
- A, Yes.: The stub's behavior depends on its electrical length, so it cannot work at all frequencies. It is tuned to one band.
- B, No, the short also kills the radio signals.: At the tuned frequency the quarter-wave stub looks like an open circuit. It passes the radio signal while shorting lightning to ground.
- C, No, the short enhances the radio signal at the tuned band.: The stub doesn't amplify or enhance the signal. At its tuned band it is simply transparent to RF while grounding DC surges.