Element 3 Question 3-30D1
C3D30: Op Amps
What is the main advantage of using an op-amp audio filter over a passive LC audio filter?
- Op-amps are largely immune to vibration and temperature change.
- Most LC filter manufacturers have retooled to make op-amp filters.
- Op-amps are readily available in a wide variety of operational voltages and frequency ranges.
- Op-amps exhibit gain rather than insertion loss. (correct answer)
Correct answer: D, Op-amps exhibit gain rather than insertion loss.
Explanation
A passive LC filter can only lose signal: some of the input is always dissipated, which is called insertion loss. An op-amp active filter uses resistors and capacitors around an amplifier, so it can filter and amplify at the same time, giving gain instead of loss. It also avoids the large, costly inductors that audio frequencies would otherwise require.
Why the other answers are wrong
- A, Op-amps are largely immune to vibration and temperature change.: The resistors and capacitors in an active filter still drift with temperature, so immunity to vibration and heat is not the main advantage.
- B, Most LC filter manufacturers have retooled to make op-amp filters.: A claim about manufacturers retooling is not an engineering advantage, and LC filters remain widely made.
- C, Op-amps are readily available in a wide variety of operational voltages and frequency ranges.: Op-amps have limited bandwidth, while LC filters work up to RF, so a range of voltages and frequencies is not what sets them apart.