Element 3 Question 3-46F6
C3F46: Filters and IF Amplifiers
When would it be more desirable to use an m-derived filter over a constant-k filter?
- When the response must be maximally flat at one frequency.
- When the number of components must be minimized.
- When high power levels must be filtered.
- When you need more attenuation at a certain frequency that is too close to the cut-off frequency for a constant-k filter. (correct answer)
Correct answer: D, When you need more attenuation at a certain frequency that is too close to the cut-off frequency for a constant-k filter.
Explanation
A constant-k filter's attenuation rises only gradually just past cutoff. An m-derived section adds a resonant element that puts a sharp attenuation peak (a pole) at a chosen frequency close to cutoff. Use it when an unwanted signal sits too near the cutoff for a constant-k filter to reject.
Why the other answers are wrong
- A, When the response must be maximally flat at one frequency.: Maximal flatness describes a Butterworth response. It is not the reason to choose an m-derived section.
- B, When the number of components must be minimized.: An m-derived section adds a resonant trap element, so it generally uses more components, not fewer.
- C, When high power levels must be filtered.: Power handling depends on component ratings, not on whether the design is constant-k or m-derived.