Element 3 Question 3-97P5
C3P97: INMARSAT Communications Systems-2
When INMARSAT-B and INMARSAT-C terminals are compared:
- INMARSAT-C antennas are small and omni-directional, while INMARSAT-B antennas are larger and directional. (correct answer)
- INMARSAT-B antennas are bulkier but omni-directional, while INMARSAT-C antennas are smaller and parabolic, for aiming at the satellite.
- INMARSAT-B antennas are parabolic and smaller for higher gain, while INMARSAT-C antennas are larger but omni-directional.
- INMARSAT-C antennas are smaller but omni-directional, while INMARSAT-B antennas are parabolic for lower gain.
Correct answer: A, INMARSAT-C antennas are small and omni-directional, while INMARSAT-B antennas are larger and directional.
Explanation
Inmarsat-C needs only a few hundred bits per second, so a small, low-gain omnidirectional antenna is enough. It needs no aiming or stabilization. Inmarsat-B carried voice and 64 kbps data, which required a high-gain parabolic dish. That dish is larger and heavier, and it must be steered to track the satellite as the ship moves. The general rule: a higher data rate needs more antenna gain, and more gain means a directional antenna.
Why the other answers are wrong
- B, INMARSAT-B antennas are bulkier but omni-directional, while INMARSAT-C antennas are smaller and parabolic, for aiming at the satellite.: It swaps the systems. The Inmarsat-B dish is the directional antenna, and the omnidirectional antenna belongs to Inmarsat-C.
- C, INMARSAT-B antennas are parabolic and smaller for higher gain, while INMARSAT-C antennas are larger but omni-directional.: The sizes are reversed. Inmarsat-B dishes are the larger ones, and Inmarsat-C's omnidirectional antenna is the small one.
- D, INMARSAT-C antennas are smaller but omni-directional, while INMARSAT-B antennas are parabolic for lower gain.: A parabolic dish gives higher gain, not lower. That gain is exactly why Inmarsat-B needed one.