Element 8 Question 8-3A5
C8A03: Frequency and Wavelength
The major advantage of an S-band RADAR over an X-band RADAR is:
- It is less affected by weather conditions. (correct answer)
- It has greater bearing resolution.
- It is mechanically less complex.
- It has greater power output.
Correct answer: A, It is less affected by weather conditions.
Explanation
S-band radar works near 3 GHz, a wavelength of about 10 cm. Rain, snow and sea spray attenuate and scatter it much less than X-band near 9.4 GHz, a wavelength of about 3 cm. The S-band set therefore keeps detecting targets in heavy weather and shows less rain and sea clutter. That is why large ships often carry one radar on each band.
Why the other answers are wrong
- B, It has greater bearing resolution.: This is backwards. With an antenna of the same size, the shorter X-band wavelength gives a narrower beam and better bearing resolution.
- C, It is mechanically less complex.: The operating band does not make a set mechanically simpler. S-band actually needs a larger antenna to reach a comparable beamwidth.
- D, It has greater power output.: Power output is a design choice, not a property of the band. Neither band inherently transmits more power.