Amateur Extra Question E1A04
E1A: Frequency privileges; signal frequency range; automatic message forwarding; stations aboard ships or aircraft; power restriction on 630- and 2200-meter bands
May an Extra class operator answer the CQ of a station on 3.601 MHz LSB phone?
- Yes, the entire signal will be inside the SSB allocation for Extra class operators
- Yes, the displayed frequency is within the 75-meter phone band segment
- No, the sideband components will extend beyond the edge of the phone band segment (correct answer)
- No, US stations are not permitted to use phone emissions below 3.610 MHz
Correct answer: C, No, the sideband components will extend beyond the edge of the phone band segment
Explanation
The Extra class 75 m phone segment begins at 3.600 MHz. An LSB signal with its carrier at 3.601 MHz extends about 3 kHz lower, to around 3.598 MHz. Part of it therefore lands in the CW/data segment below 3.600 MHz. Section 97.307(b) requires emissions to stay inside the authorized segment, so answering on that frequency would not be legal.
Why the other answers are wrong
- A, Yes, the entire signal will be inside the SSB allocation for Extra class operators: Only the displayed carrier is inside the phone segment; the lower sideband extends roughly 3 kHz below it, past 3.600 MHz.
- B, Yes, the displayed frequency is within the 75-meter phone band segment: The displayed frequency is the suppressed carrier, not the whole signal; legality depends on where the sideband falls, and here it falls below 3.600 MHz.
- D, No, US stations are not permitted to use phone emissions below 3.610 MHz: Extra class phone privileges start at 3.600 MHz, not 3.610 MHz; the problem is the LSB signal spreading below its carrier, not a 3.610 MHz limit.