Amateur Extra Question E1A08
E1A: Frequency privileges; signal frequency range; automatic message forwarding; stations aboard ships or aircraft; power restriction on 630- and 2200-meter bands
If a station in a message forwarding system inadvertently forwards a message that is in violation of FCC rules, who is primarily accountable for the rules violation?
- The control operator of the packet bulletin board station
- The control operator of the originating station (correct answer)
- The control operators of all the stations in the system
- The control operators of all the stations in the system not authenticating the source from which they accept communications
Correct answer: B, The control operator of the originating station
Explanation
Section 97.219(b) makes the control operator of the station that originates a message primarily accountable for any rule violation in it. Under 97.219(c), forwarding stations that inadvertently relay a violative message are not accountable. They must, however, stop passing it once they become aware of it. Responsibility rests with whoever put the message into the system.
Why the other answers are wrong
- A, The control operator of the packet bulletin board station: A bulletin board station is only a forwarding point, and 97.219(c) excuses forwarding stations that relay a violation inadvertently.
- C, The control operators of all the stations in the system: Accountability is not spread across the whole system. The originator is primarily accountable, and inadvertent forwarders are excused.
- D, The control operators of all the stations in the system not authenticating the source from which they accept communications: The authentication duty in 97.219(d) applies only to the first forwarding station, which must authenticate its source or accept accountability. Primary accountability stays with the originator.
Rule: §97.219