Amateur Extra Question E2E11
E2E: Operating methods: digital modes and procedures for HF
What is the difference between direct FSK and audio FSK?
- Direct FSK modulates the transmitter VFO (correct answer)
- Direct FSK occupies less bandwidth
- Direct FSK can transmit higher baud rates
- All these choices are correct
Correct answer: A, Direct FSK modulates the transmitter VFO
Explanation
In direct FSK (true FSK), a keying line shifts the transmitter's oscillator (VFO) between the mark and space frequencies. In audio FSK (AFSK), a computer or modem generates mark and space audio tones and feeds them into an SSB transmitter's audio input. Both produce the same RF signal when properly adjusted. The difference is where the frequency shift is created.
Why the other answers are wrong
- B, Direct FSK occupies less bandwidth: With the same shift and baud rate, direct FSK and a clean AFSK signal occupy essentially the same bandwidth.
- C, Direct FSK can transmit higher baud rates: Neither method is inherently limited to lower baud rates; the method of generating the shift does not set the baud rate.
- D, All these choices are correct: Only the VFO statement is true; equal bandwidth and no inherent baud-rate advantage make the other two statements false.