Amateur Extra Question E3A01
E3A: Electromagnetic Waves and Specialized Propagation: Earth-Moon-Earth (EME) communications; meteor scatter; microwave tropospheric and scatter propagation; auroral propagation; daily variation of ionospheric propagation; circular polarization
What is the approximate maximum separation measured along the surface of the Earth between two stations communicating by EME?
- 2,000 miles, if the moon is at perigee
- 2,000 miles, if the moon is at apogee
- 5,000 miles, if the moon is at perigee
- 12,000 miles, if the moon is “visible” by both stations (correct answer)
Correct answer: D, 12,000 miles, if the moon is “visible” by both stations
Explanation
An EME contact needs only one thing: both stations must see the Moon at the same moment. The Moon is about 240,000 miles away, so it is above the horizon for nearly half the globe at once. Two stations on opposite sides of that half, each with the Moon low on the horizon, can be roughly half of Earth's 24,900-mile circumference apart, about 12,000 miles.
Why the other answers are wrong
- A, 2,000 miles, if the moon is at perigee: 2,000 miles is a typical single-hop ionospheric limit; EME is not bound by it, and perigee affects path loss, not how far apart stations can be.
- B, 2,000 miles, if the moon is at apogee: Apogee only adds a little path loss; the 2,000-mile figure confuses EME with terrestrial skip distances.
- C, 5,000 miles, if the moon is at perigee: Perigee doesn't limit separation; the only requirement is a mutually visible Moon, which allows far more than 5,000 miles.