Amateur Extra Question E3A09
E3A: Electromagnetic Waves and Specialized Propagation: Earth-Moon-Earth (EME) communications; meteor scatter; microwave tropospheric and scatter propagation; auroral propagation; daily variation of ionospheric propagation; circular polarization
Which of the following frequency ranges is most suited for meteor-scatter communications?
- 1.8 MHz - 1.9 MHz
- 10 MHz - 14 MHz
- 28 MHz - 148 MHz (correct answer)
- 220 MHz - 450 MHz
Correct answer: C, 28 MHz - 148 MHz
Explanation
Meteor trails reflect lower VHF frequencies best, and the 6 meter band (50 MHz) is the classic choice. The 10 m and 2 m bands also work. At HF, normal ionospheric skip and noise swamp the brief trail reflections. Above about 150 MHz, the reflected signal from a trail drops sharply and lasts only a short time. The 28 MHz to 148 MHz range is therefore the best fit.
Why the other answers are wrong
- A, 1.8 MHz - 1.9 MHz: The 160 m band depends on D- and E-region absorption and refraction; meteor pings would be lost among normal propagation and high noise.
- B, 10 MHz - 14 MHz: At 10 MHz to 14 MHz, regular F-region skip dominates, so short meteor reflections add little and are hard to tell apart.
- D, 220 MHz - 450 MHz: Meteor scatter is possible at 220 MHz to 450 MHz, but trail reflections there are much weaker and shorter, so contacts are hard to complete.