Amateur Extra Question E7B08
E7B: Amplifiers: class of operation; vacuum tube and solid-state circuits; distortion and intermodulation; spurious and parasitic suppression; switching-type amplifiers
Why are switching amplifiers more efficient than linear amplifiers?
- Switching amplifiers operate at higher voltages
- The switching device is at saturation or cutoff most of the time (correct answer)
- Linear amplifiers have high gain resulting in higher harmonic content
- Switching amplifiers use push-pull circuits
Correct answer: B, The switching device is at saturation or cutoff most of the time
Explanation
Power dissipated in the device is P = V x I. In saturation the device is fully on, with nearly zero voltage across it. At cutoff it is fully off, with nearly zero current through it. Either way, the V x I product is tiny. A switching amplifier spends almost all its time in these two states, while a linear amplifier operates in between with both voltage and current present, wasting power as heat.
Why the other answers are wrong
- A, Switching amplifiers operate at higher voltages: Supply voltage level does not set efficiency; what matters is how much voltage and current coexist across the active device.
- C, Linear amplifiers have high gain resulting in higher harmonic content: Gain does not determine efficiency, and harmonic content is a distortion issue, not the reason switching designs waste less power.
- D, Switching amplifiers use push-pull circuits: Push-pull is a circuit arrangement used in both linear and switching amplifiers, so it cannot explain the efficiency difference.