Amateur Extra Question E7D10
E7D: Power supplies and voltage regulators; solar array charge controllers
Why is a switching type power supply less expensive and lighter than an equivalent linear power supply?
- The inverter design does not require an output filter circuit
- The control circuitry uses less current, therefore smaller heat sinks are required
- The high frequency inverter design uses much smaller transformers and filter components for an equivalent power output (correct answer)
- It recovers power from the unused portion of the AC cycle, thus using fewer components
Correct answer: C, The high frequency inverter design uses much smaller transformers and filter components for an equivalent power output
Explanation
A switching supply converts power at tens or hundreds of kilohertz instead of 60 Hz. The core size a transformer needs, and the inductance and capacitance a filter needs, fall as frequency rises. So magnetics and filter parts handling the same power are much smaller, lighter and cheaper than the bulky 60 Hz transformer and large capacitors in a linear supply.
Why the other answers are wrong
- A, The inverter design does not require an output filter circuit: A switching supply does need an output filter to smooth its pulses. That filter is simply smaller because the frequency is high.
- B, The control circuitry uses less current, therefore smaller heat sinks are required: Heat sinks shrink because the switch dissipates little power, not because the control circuitry draws less current.
- D, It recovers power from the unused portion of the AC cycle, thus using fewer components: Switching supplies don't recover an unused part of the AC cycle. The savings come from high-frequency operation.