Amateur Extra Question E9A10
E9A: Basic antenna parameters: radiation resistance, gain, beamwidth, efficiency; effective radiated power (ERP) and effective isotropic radiated power (EIRP)
Which of the following improves the efficiency of a ground-mounted quarter-wave vertical antenna?
- Installing a ground radial system (correct answer)
- Isolating the coax shield from ground
- Shortening the radiating element
- All these choices are correct
Correct answer: A, Installing a ground radial system
Explanation
A ground-mounted quarter-wave vertical relies on a ground return path for its current. Lossy soil adds loss resistance in series with the roughly 36 ohm radiation resistance. A radial system gives the return currents a low-resistance path, so less power is lost in the soil and efficiency rises.
Why the other answers are wrong
- B, Isolating the coax shield from ground: Isolating the coax shield from ground removes the counterpoise the vertical needs, which makes losses and feed line radiation worse, not better.
- C, Shortening the radiating element: Shortening the element lowers radiation resistance, so fixed ground and conductor losses take a larger share of the power and efficiency drops.
- D, All these choices are correct: Only installing radials helps. Isolating the shield and shortening the element both reduce efficiency.