Amateur Extra Question E9B11
E9B: Antenna patterns and designs: azimuth and elevation patterns; gain as a function of pattern; antenna modeling
What is a disadvantage of decreasing the number of wire segments in an antenna model below 10 segments per half-wavelength?
- Ground conductivity will not be accurately modeled
- The resulting design will favor radiation of harmonic energy
- The computed feed point impedance may be incorrect (correct answer)
- The antenna will become mechanically unstable
Correct answer: C, The computed feed point impedance may be incorrect
Explanation
Each segment holds a single value of current, so the model approximates the smooth current distribution as a series of steps. With fewer than about 10 segments per half-wavelength, that staircase is too coarse to follow the real current. The computed results suffer, especially the feed point impedance, which depends on the current at the source segment.
Why the other answers are wrong
- A, Ground conductivity will not be accurately modeled: Ground conductivity is a separate model input, and it is unaffected by how finely the wires are segmented.
- B, The resulting design will favor radiation of harmonic energy: Segmentation affects only computational accuracy; it cannot make a physical antenna favor harmonic radiation.
- D, The antenna will become mechanically unstable: Segments exist only in software, so the segment count has no bearing on the real antenna's mechanical strength.