Amateur Extra Question E9D03
E9D: Yagi antennas; parabolic reflectors; feed point impedance and loading of electrically short antennas; antenna Q; RF grounding
What is the most efficient location for a loading coil on an electrically short whip?
- Near the center of the vertical radiator (correct answer)
- As low as possible on the vertical radiator
- At a voltage maximum
- At a voltage null
Correct answer: A, Near the center of the vertical radiator
Explanation
A coil placed above the base keeps the current high along the whole lower section below it. This raises radiation resistance and efficiency compared with base loading. Moving the coil even higher calls for much more inductance, which brings more loss resistance. So placing it near the center of the radiator gives the best overall efficiency.
Why the other answers are wrong
- B, As low as possible on the vertical radiator: Base loading is easy to build, but current falls off right above the feed point, so radiation resistance and efficiency are lowest there.
- C, At a voltage maximum: The voltage maximum is at the top tip; a coil there would need a very large inductance and leaves little useful radiator above it.
- D, At a voltage null: On a short whip the voltage minimum is near the base (current maximum), which is the inefficient base-loading position.