Amateur Extra Question E9D06
E9D: Yagi antennas; parabolic reflectors; feed point impedance and loading of electrically short antennas; antenna Q; RF grounding
What happens to SWR bandwidth when one or more loading coils are used to resonate an electrically short antenna?
- It is increased
- It is decreased (correct answer)
- It is unchanged if the loading coil is located at the feed point
- It is unchanged if the loading coil is located at a voltage maximum point
Correct answer: B, It is decreased
Explanation
An electrically short antenna has low radiation resistance. A loading coil tunes out its large capacitive reactance by storing a lot of energy, which makes the system high Q. A high-Q system's reactance changes quickly away from resonance, so the SWR rises fast and the usable bandwidth narrows. This holds wherever the coil is placed.
Why the other answers are wrong
- A, It is increased: This is backward: loading raises the Q of the system, and higher Q always narrows the SWR bandwidth.
- C, It is unchanged if the loading coil is located at the feed point: Base loading still produces a high-Q system with narrow bandwidth; coil location changes efficiency, not this basic effect.
- D, It is unchanged if the loading coil is located at a voltage maximum point: No coil position avoids the narrowing; the high Q comes from the short radiator itself plus the loading reactance.