General Question G1B06
G1B: Antenna structure limitations; good engineering and good amateur practice; beacon operation; prohibited transmissions; retransmitting radio signals
Under what conditions are state and local governments permitted to regulate amateur radio antenna structures?
- Under no circumstances, FCC rules take priority
- At any time and to any extent necessary to accomplish a legitimate purpose of the state or local entity, provided that proper filings are made with the FCC
- Only when such structures exceed 50 feet in height and are clearly visible 1,000 feet from the structure
- Amateur Service communications must be reasonably accommodated, and regulations must constitute the minimum practical to accommodate a legitimate purpose of the state or local entity (correct answer)
Correct answer: D, Amateur Service communications must be reasonably accommodated, and regulations must constitute the minimum practical to accommodate a legitimate purpose of the state or local entity
Explanation
The PRB-1 limited preemption policy is reflected in Section 97.15(b). It says state and local regulation must not preclude amateur communications. Instead, it must reasonably accommodate them and constitute the minimum practicable regulation to accomplish the local authority's legitimate purpose. Local governments can regulate antennas, but only within those limits.
Why the other answers are wrong
- A, Under no circumstances, FCC rules take priority: PRB-1 is limited preemption, not total. Local governments may still regulate antennas for legitimate purposes such as safety, provided they reasonably accommodate amateur radio.
- B, At any time and to any extent necessary to accomplish a legitimate purpose of the state or local entity, provided that proper filings are made with the FCC: Regulating 'to any extent necessary' ignores the reasonable-accommodation and minimum-practicable limits, and no FCC filing by the locality is involved.
- C, Only when such structures exceed 50 feet in height and are clearly visible 1,000 feet from the structure: PRB-1 and Part 97 set no 50-foot height or 1,000-foot visibility threshold. The test is reasonable accommodation, not a fixed height.
Rules: §97.15(b), PRB-1, 101 FCC 2d 952 (1985)