General Question G3B11
G3B: Maximum Usable Frequency; Lowest Usable Frequency; short path and long path propagation; determining propagation conditions; ionospheric refraction
What happens to HF propagation when the LUF exceeds the MUF?
- Propagation via ordinary skywave communications is not possible over that path (correct answer)
- HF communications over the path are enhanced
- Double-hop propagation along the path is more common
- Propagation over the path on all HF frequencies is enhanced
Correct answer: A, Propagation via ordinary skywave communications is not possible over that path
Explanation
The MUF is the highest frequency the ionosphere will refract back to Earth over a path. The LUF is the lowest frequency that survives D-region absorption and noise. Usable frequencies lie between the two. If the LUF rises above the MUF, that window closes: any frequency low enough to refract is absorbed, and any frequency high enough to escape absorption passes through. Normal skywave contact over that path is then impossible.
Why the other answers are wrong
- B, HF communications over the path are enhanced: Communications are not enhanced; a LUF above the MUF means no frequency can both refract and avoid absorption over the path.
- C, Double-hop propagation along the path is more common: Double-hop paths need the same usable window on each hop, so they do not become more common when that window has vanished.
- D, Propagation over the path on all HF frequencies is enhanced: No HF frequency is helped; the condition eliminates ordinary skywave on every frequency over that path.