General Question G4E06
G4E: Mobile and portable HF stations; alternative energy source operation
What is one disadvantage of using a shortened mobile antenna as opposed to a full-size antenna?
- Short antennas are more likely to cause distortion of transmitted signals
- Q of the antenna will be very low
- Operating bandwidth may be very limited (correct answer)
- Harmonic radiation may increase
Correct answer: C, Operating bandwidth may be very limited
Explanation
An antenna much shorter than a quarter wavelength has low radiation resistance. It needs a loading coil to resonate, and that gives it a high Q. High Q means a narrow bandwidth: the SWR climbs quickly as you tune away from resonance, so you may need to retune whenever you change frequency.
Why the other answers are wrong
- A, Short antennas are more likely to cause distortion of transmitted signals: A short antenna does not distort the modulation; its limitations are bandwidth and efficiency, not signal fidelity.
- B, Q of the antenna will be very low: This reverses the fact: a shortened, loaded antenna has a high Q, which is exactly why its bandwidth is narrow.
- D, Harmonic radiation may increase: Shortening the antenna does not by itself increase harmonic radiation; harmonics come from the transmitter and its filtering.