General Question G6A06
G6A: Resistors; capacitors; inductors; rectifiers; solid-state diodes and transistors; vacuum tubes; batteries
Why should wire-wound resistors not be used in RF circuits?
- The resistor’s tolerance value would not be adequate
- The resistor’s inductance could make circuit performance unpredictable (correct answer)
- The resistor could overheat
- The resistor’s internal capacitance would detune the circuit
Correct answer: B, The resistor’s inductance could make circuit performance unpredictable
Explanation
A wire-wound resistor is made by winding resistance wire into a coil, and a coil is an inductor. At RF the inductive reactance (X_L = 2πfL) becomes significant, so the part no longer behaves as a pure resistance. Tuning, impedance and filtering can then shift unpredictably. Carbon-composition, metal-film or other non-inductive resistors are used in RF circuits instead.
Why the other answers are wrong
- A, The resistor’s tolerance value would not be adequate: Wire-wound resistors are actually made to tight tolerances. Their problem at RF is reactance, not inaccuracy.
- C, The resistor could overheat: Wire-wound resistors handle heat well and are chosen for high power, so overheating is not the reason to avoid them.
- D, The resistor’s internal capacitance would detune the circuit: Some stray capacitance exists, but the winding mainly adds inductance, and that is the dominant RF problem.