General Question G9B09
G9B: Basic dipole and monopole antennas
Which of the following is an advantage of using a horizontally polarized as compared to a vertically polarized HF antenna?
- Lower ground losses (correct answer)
- Lower feed point impedance
- Shorter radials
- Lower radiation resistance
Correct answer: A, Lower ground losses
Explanation
A vertical antenna's return currents and near field interact strongly with the soil beneath it, so it needs a good radial system to keep ground losses low. A horizontal antenna at a reasonable height couples much less loss into the earth. It needs no radials and usually wastes less power in the ground.
Why the other answers are wrong
- B, Lower feed point impedance: Polarization by itself doesn't give a lower feed point impedance; a quarter-wave vertical is actually lower (about 36 ohms) than a dipole (about 73 ohms).
- C, Shorter radials: Horizontal antennas don't use radials at all, so shorter radials can't be one of their advantages.
- D, Lower radiation resistance: Lower radiation resistance is not an advantage, and a horizontal dipole's radiation resistance is higher than a quarter-wave vertical's.