General Question G9C03
G9C: Directional antennas
How do the lengths of a three-element Yagi reflector and director compare to that of the driven element?
- The reflector is longer, and the director is shorter (correct answer)
- The reflector is shorter, and the director is longer
- They are all the same length
- Relative length depends on the frequency of operation
Correct answer: A, The reflector is longer, and the director is shorter
Explanation
The reflector is cut slightly longer than the driven element, making it inductive. The director is cut slightly shorter, making it capacitive. The resulting phase shifts in the currents of these parasitic elements reinforce radiation toward the director and cancel it toward the reflector. One way to remember it: the reflector is longer and sits behind the driven element.
Why the other answers are wrong
- B, The reflector is shorter, and the director is longer: This reverses the elements; a longer element behind the driven element reflects and a shorter one in front directs.
- C, They are all the same length: If all elements were the same length, there would be no phase difference to create directivity or front-to-back ratio.
- D, Relative length depends on the frequency of operation: Element lengths do scale with frequency, but the reflector-longer, director-shorter relationship holds on every band.