Technician Question T9A04
T9A: Antennas: vertical and horizontal polarization, concept of antenna gain, definition and types of beam antennas, antenna loading, common portable and mobile antennas, relationships between resonant length and frequency, dipole pattern
What is a disadvantage of a handheld radio transceiver’s short flexible antenna compared to a full-sized quarter-wave antenna?
- It has low efficiency (correct answer)
- It transmits only circularly polarized signals
- It is more susceptible to receiver desensitization
- It only works on analog signals, not digital ones
Correct answer: A, It has low efficiency
Explanation
A rubber-duck antenna is much shorter than a quarter wavelength and relies on internal loading to resonate. That gives it low radiation resistance and higher losses, so more power becomes heat and less is radiated. It also captures weaker signals than a full-size quarter-wave whip, which hurts range in both directions.
Why the other answers are wrong
- B, It transmits only circularly polarized signals: A short vertical whip is linearly (vertically) polarized; circular polarization requires special designs such as helical or crossed elements.
- C, It is more susceptible to receiver desensitization: Desensitization comes from strong nearby signals overloading the receiver front end, not from the antenna being short.
- D, It only works on analog signals, not digital ones: An antenna is indifferent to modulation; analog and digital signals radiate the same way at a given frequency.