Element 8 Question 8-18B2
C8B18: Power Supplies
The characteristics of a field-effect transistor (FET) used in a modern RADAR switching power supply can be compared as follows:
- “On” state compares to a bipolar transistor. “Off” state compares to a 1-Megohm resistor.
- “On” state compares to a pure resistor. “Off” state compares to a mechanical relay. (correct answer)
- “On” state compares to an low resistance inductor. “Off” state compares to a 10-Megohm resistor.
- “On” state compares to a resistor. “Off” state compares to a capacitor.
Correct answer: B, “On” state compares to a pure resistor. “Off” state compares to a mechanical relay.
Explanation
A power MOSFET switched fully on conducts through a channel with a small, nearly fixed resistance (RDS(on)), so it acts like a pure resistor. Fully off, it passes almost no current, like the open contacts of a relay. Switching supplies run the FET only in these two states, which keeps power loss low.
Why the other answers are wrong
- A, “On” state compares to a bipolar transistor. “Off” state compares to a 1-Megohm resistor.: A bipolar transistor has a fixed saturation voltage, not a resistance, and an off FET has far more resistance than 1 MΩ.
- C, “On” state compares to an low resistance inductor. “Off” state compares to a 10-Megohm resistor.: An on FET channel is resistive, not inductive, and the off-state resistance is far above 10 MΩ, approaching an open circuit.
- D, “On” state compares to a resistor. “Off” state compares to a capacitor.: The on state is right, but an off FET is not modeled as a capacitor; its small parasitic capacitance matters only during switching edges.