Element 8 Question 8-18B5
C8B18: Power Supplies
A major consideration for the use of a switching regulator power supply over a linear regulator is:
- The switching regulator has better regulation.
- The linear regulator does not require a transformer to step down AC line voltages to a usable level.
- The switching regulator can be used in nearly all applications requiring regulated voltage.
- The overall efficiency of a switching regulator is much higher than a linear power supply. (correct answer)
Correct answer: D, The overall efficiency of a switching regulator is much higher than a linear power supply.
Explanation
A linear regulator drops the excess voltage across a pass transistor in its active region and wastes it as heat, so efficiency is often only 30–60%. A switching regulator drives its transistor fully on or fully off at high frequency and smooths the output with inductors and capacitors, so little power is lost. Efficiencies of 80–95% are typical, which allows smaller heat sinks and transformers.
Why the other answers are wrong
- A, The switching regulator has better regulation.: Linear regulators usually regulate more tightly, with less ripple and noise. Regulation quality is not the switcher's advantage.
- B, The linear regulator does not require a transformer to step down AC line voltages to a usable level.: A conventional linear supply does need a bulky 50/60 Hz step-down transformer. Off-line switchers avoid it by rectifying the line and using a small high-frequency transformer.
- C, The switching regulator can be used in nearly all applications requiring regulated voltage.: Linear regulators also serve nearly every regulated application. Switcher ripple and RF noise make switchers a poor choice for some sensitive circuits, so this is no distinguishing advantage.