Element 8 Question 8-26C6
C8C26: Power Supplies
The nominal output high of the comparator shown in Fig. 8C11 is 4.5 volts. Choose the most correct statement which describes the trip points.
- Upper trip point is 4.5 volts. Lower trip point is approximately 0 volts.
- Upper trip point is 2.5 volts. Lower trip point is approximately 2.0 volts.
- Upper trip point is 900 microvolts. Lower trip point is approximately 0 volts.
- Upper trip point is +1.285 volts. Lower trip point is -1.285 volts. (correct answer)
Correct answer: D, Upper trip point is +1.285 volts. Lower trip point is -1.285 volts.
Explanation
The 5 kΩ and 2 kΩ resistors feed back a fraction of the output to the + input, making a Schmitt trigger. That fraction is 2 kΩ / (5 kΩ + 2 kΩ) = 0.2857. With the output at +4.5 V, the upper trip point is 4.5 V × 0.2857 ≈ +1.285 V. With the output at −4.5 V (a split supply), the lower trip point is ≈ −1.285 V. The difference between them is the hysteresis.
Why the other answers are wrong
- A, Upper trip point is 4.5 volts. Lower trip point is approximately 0 volts.: 4.5 V is the output level itself. The trip point is only the 2/7 fraction of it that the divider feeds back to the + input.
- B, Upper trip point is 2.5 volts. Lower trip point is approximately 2.0 volts.: These values don't come from the 5 kΩ/2 kΩ divider. The trip points are symmetrical about zero, not 2.5 V and 2.0 V.
- C, Upper trip point is 900 microvolts. Lower trip point is approximately 0 volts.: 900 µV is far too small. The positive feedback divider sets the threshold at about 29% of the output swing, over a volt.