Element 8 Question 8-49F1
C8F49: Installation
Why is coaxial cable often used for S-band installations instead of a waveguide:
- Losses can be kept reasonable at S-band frequencies and the installation cost is lower. (correct answer)
- A waveguide will not support the power density required for modern S-band RADAR transmitters.
- S-band waveguide flanges show too much leakage and are unsafe for use near personnel.
- Dimensions for S-band waveguide do not permit a rugged enough installation for use by ships at sea.
Correct answer: A, Losses can be kept reasonable at S-band frequencies and the installation cost is lower.
Explanation
S-band radar operates near 3 GHz, a wavelength of about 10 cm. Waveguide size scales with wavelength, so S-band guide is large, heavy and costly to route through a ship. At 3 GHz, good-quality coax still has acceptable loss over a typical run, and it is cheaper and easier to install. At X-band (about 9 GHz), coax loss becomes too high, so waveguide is used there.
Why the other answers are wrong
- B, A waveguide will not support the power density required for modern S-band RADAR transmitters.: Waveguide actually handles high power better than coax. Power handling is not the reason coax is chosen at S-band.
- C, S-band waveguide flanges show too much leakage and are unsafe for use near personnel.: Properly mated and tightened waveguide flanges don't leak dangerously. Leakage is not a characteristic of S-band guide.
- D, Dimensions for S-band waveguide do not permit a rugged enough installation for use by ships at sea.: Large S-band waveguide is mechanically very rugged. Its drawback is bulk and cost, not fragility.