Amateur Extra Question E5D10
E5D: RF effects in components and circuits: skin effect; real and reactive power; electrical length of conductors
As a conductor’s diameter increases, what is the effect on its electrical length?
- Thickness has no effect on electrical length
- It varies randomly
- It decreases
- It increases (correct answer)
Correct answer: D, It increases
Explanation
A thicker conductor has more capacitance along its length and at its ends. This slows the wave on it, so the velocity factor drops. The same physical length then holds more wavelengths, which means it is electrically longer and resonates at a lower frequency. That is why a fat dipole element must be cut a little shorter than a thin wire for the same frequency.
Why the other answers are wrong
- A, Thickness has no effect on electrical length: Diameter does matter: added capacitance lowers the velocity factor, so conductor thickness changes electrical length.
- B, It varies randomly: The effect is predictable and repeatable, not random: a greater diameter always makes the conductor electrically longer.
- C, It decreases: This reverses the effect: a greater diameter lowers the velocity factor, so the conductor gets electrically longer, not shorter.