Amateur Extra Question E5D11
E5D: RF effects in components and circuits: skin effect; real and reactive power; electrical length of conductors
How much real power is consumed in a circuit consisting of a 100-ohm resistor in series with a 100-ohm inductive reactance drawing 1 ampere?
- 70.7 watts
- 100 watts (correct answer)
- 141.4 watts
- 200 watts
Correct answer: B, 100 watts
Explanation
Only resistance consumes real power; reactance just stores energy and returns it. The 1 A series current flows through the 100 ohm resistor, so P = I² x R = (1 A)² x 100 ohm = 100 W. The impedance is 141.4 ohm, which gives 141.4 VA of apparent power, but the reactive part contributes no watts.
Why the other answers are wrong
- A, 70.7 watts: 70.7 W comes from wrongly applying the 0.707 power factor to the resistor's 100 W. I²R already gives the true power directly.
- C, 141.4 watts: 141.4 W treats the apparent power, I² x Z = 1 x 141.4 VA, as real power. The reactance consumes no watts.
- D, 200 watts: 200 W wrongly adds resistance and reactance as if both dissipated power; reactance consumes nothing, and they don't even add arithmetically.