Amateur Extra Question E9D10
E9D: Yagi antennas; parabolic reflectors; feed point impedance and loading of electrically short antennas; antenna Q; RF grounding
How does radiation resistance of a base-fed whip antenna change below its resonant frequency?
- Radiation resistance increases
- Radiation resistance decreases (correct answer)
- Radiation resistance becomes imaginary
- Radiation resistance does not depend on frequency
Correct answer: B, Radiation resistance decreases
Explanation
Below its resonant frequency, a fixed-length whip is a smaller fraction of a wavelength, so it is electrically shorter. A short monopole's radiation resistance is roughly proportional to the square of its height in wavelengths, so it drops quickly as frequency falls. This is why short mobile antennas can have just a few ohms of radiation resistance.
Why the other answers are wrong
- A, Radiation resistance increases: This reverses the trend; radiation resistance rises only as the antenna becomes electrically longer, which happens at higher frequencies.
- C, Radiation resistance becomes imaginary: The capacitive reactance that appears is the imaginary part of the impedance; radiation resistance itself always stays a real quantity.
- D, Radiation resistance does not depend on frequency: Radiation resistance depends on electrical length, and electrical length changes with frequency for a fixed physical length.