Amateur Extra Question E9D11
E9D: Yagi antennas; parabolic reflectors; feed point impedance and loading of electrically short antennas; antenna Q; RF grounding
Why do most two-element Yagis with normal spacing have a reflector instead of a director?
- Lower SWR
- Higher receiving directivity factor
- Greater front-to-side
- Higher gain (correct answer)
Correct answer: D, Higher gain
Explanation
At typical element spacings of about 0.1 to 0.2 wavelength, a driven element paired with a longer reflector gives slightly more forward gain than one paired with a shorter director. Because gain is usually the main goal of a two-element beam, most designs use the reflector arrangement.
Why the other answers are wrong
- A, Lower SWR: Feed point impedance can be matched in either arrangement, so SWR is not what decides between a reflector and a director.
- B, Higher receiving directivity factor: Receiving directivity factor is a receive-pattern figure of merit; it is not the usual reason two-element Yagis are built with a reflector.
- C, Greater front-to-side: Front-to-side ratio is not the design criterion here; the reflector is chosen for its slightly better forward gain.