Amateur Extra Question E9F03
E9F: Transmission lines: characteristics of open and shorted feed lines; coax versus open wire; velocity factor; electrical length; coaxial cable dielectrics; microstrip
Why is the electrical length of a coaxial cable longer than its physical length?
- Skin effect is less pronounced in the coaxial cable
- Skin effect is more pronounced in the coaxial cable
- Electromagnetic waves move faster in coaxial cable than in air
- Electromagnetic waves move more slowly in a coaxial cable than in air (correct answer)
Correct answer: D, Electromagnetic waves move more slowly in a coaxial cable than in air
Explanation
The dielectric inside coax slows the wave, so during one RF cycle the wave covers less distance than it would in air. A given piece of cable therefore holds more wavelengths than the same length of free space. Its electrical length (physical length ÷ VF) is greater than its physical length. For example, 1 m of VF 0.66 coax is about 1.52 m electrically.
Why the other answers are wrong
- A, Skin effect is less pronounced in the coaxial cable: Skin effect concentrates current near conductor surfaces and raises loss. It does not change the wave's speed or the electrical length.
- B, Skin effect is more pronounced in the coaxial cable: Stronger skin effect only adds resistive loss. Electrical length depends on propagation speed, which the dielectric sets.
- C, Electromagnetic waves move faster in coaxial cable than in air: This is backwards. Nothing travels faster than in air or vacuum, and a faster wave would make the electrical length shorter, not longer.