Amateur Extra Question E9F07
E9F: Transmission lines: characteristics of open and shorted feed lines; coax versus open wire; velocity factor; electrical length; coaxial cable dielectrics; microstrip
How does parallel conductor transmission line compare to coaxial cable with a plastic dielectric?
- Lower loss (correct answer)
- Higher SWR
- Smaller reflection coefficient
- Lower velocity factor
Correct answer: A, Lower loss
Explanation
In open-wire or ladder line, most of the field is in air, and the conductors are widely spaced. Dielectric loss is therefore tiny, and current-related losses are small, so loss per meter is far lower than in plastic-dielectric coax. The advantage becomes even larger when the line runs at high SWR, which open-wire line tolerates well.
Why the other answers are wrong
- B, Higher SWR: SWR depends on how well the load matches the line's impedance, not on whether the line is open-wire or coax.
- C, Smaller reflection coefficient: Reflection coefficient is set by the load-to-line impedance mismatch, not by the type of feed line.
- D, Lower velocity factor: This is backwards. With mostly air as the dielectric, parallel line has a higher velocity factor (about 0.9 or more) than solid coax (about 0.66).