Amateur Extra Question E9F08
E9F: Transmission lines: characteristics of open and shorted feed lines; coax versus open wire; velocity factor; electrical length; coaxial cable dielectrics; microstrip
Which of the following is a significant difference between foam dielectric coaxial cable and solid dielectric coaxial cable, assuming all other parameters are the same?
- Foam dielectric coaxial cable has lower safe maximum operating voltage
- Foam dielectric coaxial cable has lower loss per unit of length
- Foam dielectric coaxial cable has higher velocity factor
- All these choices are correct (correct answer)
Correct answer: D, All these choices are correct
Explanation
Foam dielectric is mostly gas, so it differs from solid dielectric in three ways. Its lower dielectric constant raises the velocity factor (about 0.8 versus 0.66). It also has less dielectric loss, so loss per meter is lower. But the foam withstands less voltage and can let the center conductor shift, so the safe maximum voltage is lower. All three statements are true.
Why the other answers are wrong
- A, Foam dielectric coaxial cable has lower safe maximum operating voltage: True, since foam has lower dielectric strength than solid plastic, but this is only one of three correct differences.
- B, Foam dielectric coaxial cable has lower loss per unit of length: True, since foam's mostly-air dielectric absorbs less RF, but lower loss is not the only correct difference.
- C, Foam dielectric coaxial cable has higher velocity factor: True, since foam's lower dielectric constant speeds up the wave, but higher velocity factor is not the only correct difference.