General Question G4C07
G4C: Interference to consumer electronics; grounding and bonding
Why should soldered joints not be used in lightning protection ground connections?
- A soldered joint will likely be destroyed by the heat of a lightning strike (correct answer)
- Solder flux will prevent a low conductivity connection
- Solder has too high a dielectric constant to provide adequate lightning protection
- All these choices are correct
Correct answer: A, A soldered joint will likely be destroyed by the heat of a lightning strike
Explanation
Lightning surge current is huge, and its heating can melt solder, which has a low melting point. Once the solder melts, the joint can open, leaving the protective ground disconnected just when it is needed. Lightning ground connections should therefore use mechanical clamps or exothermic (welded) bonds rather than solder.
Why the other answers are wrong
- B, Solder flux will prevent a low conductivity connection: Flux does not create a special connection problem. The wording also makes no sense, since preventing a low-conductivity connection would be a benefit.
- C, Solder has too high a dielectric constant to provide adequate lightning protection: Solder is a metal conductor, so dielectric constant is not a meaningful property for it here.
- D, All these choices are correct: Only the statement about heat destroying the joint is valid. The flux and dielectric-constant claims are false.