Amateur Extra Question E4C11
E4C: Receiver performance: phase noise, noise floor, image rejection, minimum detectable signal (MDS), increasing signal-to-noise ratio and dynamic range, noise figure, reciprocal mixing; selectivity; SDR non-linearity; use of attenuators at low frequencies
Why does input attenuation reduce receiver overload on the lower frequency HF bands with little or no impact on signal-to-noise ratio?
- The attenuator has a low-pass filter to increase the strength of lower frequency signals
- The attenuator has a noise filter to suppress interference
- Signals are attenuated separately from the noise
- Atmospheric noise is generally greater than internally generated noise even after attenuation (correct answer)
Correct answer: D, Atmospheric noise is generally greater than internally generated noise even after attenuation
Explanation
Below about 10 MHz, atmospheric and man-made noise arriving at the antenna is far stronger than the noise a modern receiver generates internally. An attenuator lowers the wanted signal and the band noise by the same amount, so the S/N ratio is set by the external noise and barely changes. The strong signals that were overloading the front end are reduced, which eases overload.
Why the other answers are wrong
- A, The attenuator has a low-pass filter to increase the strength of lower frequency signals: An input attenuator is a broadband resistive pad that reduces every signal; it cannot boost lower-frequency signals, and a filter that boosted them would worsen overload.
- B, The attenuator has a noise filter to suppress interference: A simple attenuator has no noise filtering; it reduces noise and signal together, which is why S/N stays roughly the same.
- C, Signals are attenuated separately from the noise: An attenuator cannot separate signals from noise; both arrive together on the feed line and are reduced by the same number of dB.